Here’s a list of the top sugar free ice cream brands for you to enjoy! With the right choice, it can be every bit as delicious as the traditional kind!
Psst — looking for a sugar free ice cream recipe? Check out my master keto ice cream recipe or more recipes below!
Best Tasting Sugar Free Ice Cream Brands
Here are the best sugar free ice cream brands:
11. Skinny Cow, No Sugar Added Vanilla Gone Wild
Sweetener: maltodextrin, polydextrose, sorbitol, sucralose, maltitol
Best described as a sweet pillow of fluff surrounded by two soft chocolate cookies.
1 Sandwich:
- 28g TOTAL carbs
- 25g NET carbs
- 5g sugar
10. Breyers No Sugar Added
Sweetener: maltitol, maltodextrin, sucralose (Splenda)
Comes in a few flavors! Breyers also carries a brand called Carb Smart.
1 Vanilla Serving:
- 17g TOTAL carbs
- 9g NET carbs
- 5g sugar
9. Edy’s/Dreyer’s No Sugar Added
Sweetener: maltitol, sucralose (Splenda), maltodextrin, polydextrose
This ice cream comes in tons of flavors and is easy to find in most grocery stores. This is Dreyer’s “lightened up” ice cream, so it’s made with ½ the fat, and is sweetened with Splenda.
1 Vanilla Serving:
- 14g TOTAL carbs
- 8g NET carbs
- 3g sugar
8. Simple Truth Keto Ice Cream
Sweetener: erythritol, monk fruit, stevia
Krogers markets strike again with this killer and crazy affordable ice cream! They come in a few flavors — each has the perfect taste, texture, and creaminess level.
1 Choc. Chip Serving:
- 17g TOTAL carbs
- 3g NET carbs
- <1g sugar
7. Killer Creamery
Sweetener: allulose, erythritol, monk fruit
Killer Creamery is one of the few sugar free ice cream brands that use my favorite sweetener for frozen desserts: allulose! Unlike sugar alcohols, this rare sugar doesn’t recrystallize, giving each spoonful of ice cream that creamy smooth texture we all love.
1 Vanilla Serving:
- 12g TOTAL carbs
- 6g NET carbs
- 2g sugar
6. Keto Pint
Sweetener: erythritol, stevia
Not a single boring flavor on their menu! From chocolate chip cookie dough, to cake batter, to black raspberry. Yes. Please.
1 Chocolate Serving:
- 18g TOTAL carbs
- 2g NET carbs
- 1g sugar
5. Enlighted Ice Cream Bars
Sweetener: erythritol + monk fruit
SO many flavors to choose from, and SO convenient!
1 Fudge Bar:
- 11g TOTAL carbs
- 4g NET carbs
- <1g sugar
4. SO Delicious No Sugar Added
Sweetener: erythritol + monk fruit
The lowest sugar of these ice cream brands is this tasty, coconut milk-based ice cream. Surprisingly delicious, it’s sweetened with erythritol and monk fruit extract.
1 Vanilla Serving:
- 24g TOTAL carbs
- 10g NET carbs
- 2g sugar
3. Rebel Ice Cream
Sweetener: erythritol + monk fruit
Sweetened with erythritol and containing more fat than carbs, this ice cream is what keto dreams are made of! Check out their delicious and affordable flavors.
1 Vanilla Serving:
- 14g TOTAL carbs
- 4g NET carbs
- 0g sugar
2. Halo Top Ice Cream
Sweetener: inulin, erythritol, stevia
These ice creams are sweetened with stevia instead of sugar or sugar alcohols (unlike the other ice creams on this list). They’ve got around 5 grams of protein per serving, and come in a ton of flavors.
BONUS: They’ve recently added a new selection of keto ice cream to their line! These are instead sweetened with sugar alcohol (inulin and erythritol), and bring about 1g NET CARB PER SERVING + 5g per pint!
1 Vanilla Serving:
- 19g TOTAL carbs
- 16g NET carbs
- 8g sugar
1. Enlightened Ice Cream
Sweetener: erythritol + allulose
My favorite of these ice cream brands is Enlightened ice cream. They come in a ton of creative flavors, are sweetened with erythritol, and have more protein than any of the other brands (6 grams per serving in most flavors).
1 Vanilla Serving:
- 14g TOTAL carbs
- 4g NET carbs
- 3g sugar
Keto Ice Cream Recipes
Here are 3 of my favorite sugar free ice cream recipes:
- Master low carb ice cream recipe, with 4 variations!
- Avocado ice cream
- Keto popsicles
- Keto ice cream bars
Ice Cream Toppings
If sugar free is your goal, a lot of those candy, chocolatey, syrupy options are out — so try some of these sugar free ideas instead:
- Keto nuts — walnuts, peanuts, pecans, and almonds
- Unsweetened shredded coconut
- Sugar free chocolate syrup — this recipe takes 5 minutes to throw together but makes all the difference!
- Keto fruits — depending on your goals, you may be ok with adding some low sugar fruits on top.
Conclusion
There you have it friends, the best of the sugar free ice cream Walmart and sugar free ice cream Safeway have to offer! Hope you enjoy these ice cream brands! Come back to tell me what you think!
